If I could have picked 4.5 stars I would. I am 5'10”, fairly average size, 180, normal build. It feels a tad small in width, but it's the size they sell. It doesn't cover my arms as much as I am used to with more blanket style ponchos.
The quality is unreal. The hood is a huge plus, most hoods are not tailored as this is. Most hoods come to a point which looks weird, but this is well made, fits the head in a more streamlined way.
Truly, the quality is that of what I would have imagined real cloaks and capes might have been made like prior to industrialization. This feels like something Elves would wear in Lord of the Rings, quality; soft, light but with substance to it, a piece of art while remaining utilitarian.